Choosing the right PCB design software is one of the most important decisions for any electronics maker or engineer in India. EasyEDA, KiCad, and Altium Designer represent three very different approaches — cloud-based simplicity vs powerful free desktop tool vs professional enterprise solution. This comparison covers all three with honest assessments of their strengths, weaknesses, and which is right for Indian makers at each skill level.
Table of Contents
- Overview of Each Platform
- EasyEDA: Browser-Based PCB Design
- KiCad: The Open-Source Standard
- Altium Designer: Professional Grade
- Feature Comparison Table
- India-Specific Considerations
- Which to Choose: By User Type
- Frequently Asked Questions
Overview of Each Platform
All three tools create PCB Gerber files suitable for fabrication at Indian and international PCB manufacturers. The differences lie in workflow, learning curve, cost, collaboration features, and design complexity they support.
EasyEDA: Browser-Based PCB Design
EasyEDA (owned by JLCPCB’s parent company LCSC/NextPCB) is a web-based EDA tool that runs entirely in the browser with no installation required. EasyEDA Pro (the current version) is a significant upgrade with a more powerful layout engine.
Key Features
- Zero installation: Works in any modern browser on any OS, including mobile tablets
- LCSC integration: Direct import of LCSC component data (footprints, symbols, prices, stock levels) — enormous advantage for JLCPCB assembly orders
- Collaborative editing: Multiple users can edit the same project simultaneously (like Google Docs for PCBs)
- Direct JLCPCB order: One-click from EasyEDA to JLCPCB ordering page
- Free tier: Unlimited designs for personal use (cloud storage)
- Simulation: Basic SPICE simulation available
Limitations
- Requires internet connection (cloud-only, though offline export is possible)
- Less powerful router than KiCad or Altium for complex multi-layer designs
- Privacy concerns: designs stored on LCSC servers
- Component library heavily biased toward LCSC/JLCPCB ecosystem
KiCad: The Open-Source Standard
KiCad is a free, open-source, desktop-based EDA suite maintained by CERN and a global developer community. Version 8.x (2024-2026) brought major improvements making it competitive with paid tools for most use cases.
Key Features
- Completely free: No licence fee, no design size limits, no subscription
- Desktop-based: Works offline, files stored locally (important for IP protection)
- Powerful router: Push-and-shove interactive router, tuned length matching for DDR memory and high-speed differential pairs
- Large library: Thousands of components in default library; millions more via community libraries (SnapEDA, UltraLibrarian)
- 3D viewer: Excellent 3D PCB preview with component 3D models
- SPICE simulation: Integrated ngspice for circuit simulation
- Extensible: Python scripting API for custom automation
Limitations
- Steeper learning curve than EasyEDA
- No native cloud collaboration (use Git for version control)
- Component library management less streamlined than EasyEDA+LCSC combo
Altium Designer: Professional Grade
Altium Designer is the preferred PCB design tool in professional electronics companies worldwide. India’s growing electronics manufacturing sector (EMS companies, defence electronics, automotive) widely uses Altium.
Key Features
- Industry standard: Most EMS companies and PCB manufacturers accept Altium files natively
- Advanced routing: Best-in-class high-speed design rules, tuned length matching, differential pair routing
- Complete design flow: MCAD collaboration, signal integrity simulation, thermal analysis
- Altium 365: Cloud collaboration platform for team design management
- Active BOM: Real-time component pricing and availability from distributors (DigiKey, Mouser)
Cost in India (2026)
- Commercial licence: Rs 3.5-5 lakh/year per seat
- Student/Academic: Free with university email (many IITs and NITs have institutional licences)
- Altium Viewer: Free (view-only, no editing)
Feature Comparison Table
| Feature | EasyEDA Pro | KiCad 8 | Altium Designer |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cost | Free (cloud) | Free (open source) | Rs 3.5-5L/year |
| Platform | Browser (cloud) | Desktop (offline) | Desktop + cloud |
| Learning curve | Low | Medium | High |
| Router quality | Good | Excellent | Best |
| JLCPCB integration | Native | Via plugin | Manual Gerber export |
| High-speed design | Limited | Good | Industry-leading |
| Layer count | Up to 32 (Pro) | Up to 32 | Up to 32+ |
| Simulation | Basic SPICE | ngspice | Advanced SI/PI |
| Community (India) | Growing | Large | Professional |
India-Specific Considerations
- JLCPCB popularity: JLCPCB is the most popular PCB service among Indian makers due to low cost and fast shipping (7-10 days to India). EasyEDA’s native integration gives it a significant workflow advantage for JLCPCB orders.
- Local PCB manufacturers: Companies like PCBPower (India), Circuits Arcade, and Advanced Circuits (Bengaluru) accept standard Gerber files from any tool — no preference for specific software.
- Employment market: Indian electronics companies (Tata Elxsi, L&T Technology, Bosch India) use Altium. Learning Altium during college (via student licence) significantly improves job prospects for VLSI/PCB design roles.
- Startup ecosystem: Indian hardware startups typically use KiCad (free) or EasyEDA (JLCPCB integration). Very few startups can justify Altium licence cost until significant revenue stage.
Which to Choose: By User Type
- Beginner/student (first PCB ever): EasyEDA. Immediate results, JLCPCB integration makes ordering the completed board trivial.
- Hobbyist/maker (Arduino, ESP32 projects): KiCad. Better long-term investment, more powerful tools, no design size limits, large community.
- Startup/small company: KiCad for budget, or EasyEDA Pro for JLCPCB assembly workflow. Consider Altium once design complexity requires its advanced features.
- Engineering student (IIT/NIT): Learn KiCad as primary tool; use Altium student licence for exposure to industry standard.
- Professional electronics engineer: Altium Designer if your company pays. KiCad as free alternative for personal/side projects.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I transfer a project from EasyEDA to KiCad?
Yes. EasyEDA can export to KiCad format (.kicad_sch and .kicad_pcb files). The conversion is not perfect — footprints and symbols may need adjustment — but it is functional for most projects. Going from KiCad to EasyEDA is less supported.
Is EasyEDA good enough for professional PCB design?
For 2-layer boards with moderate complexity (most IoT, Arduino-based, and ESP32 projects), yes. For 4+ layer high-speed designs (USB 3.0, HDMI, DDR memory), EasyEDA Pro’s routing tools are less capable than KiCad or Altium. Professional EMS companies may not accept EasyEDA’s proprietary file format — always export Gerbers.
Does KiCad have a mobile app?
No. KiCad is a desktop application only. EasyEDA works in mobile browsers but is not optimised for touchscreens. For mobile viewing of PCB designs, use the KiCad PCB Viewer app (Android) or Altium Viewer (web-based).
Are there any Indian alternatives to these three PCB design tools?
No major Indian EDA tools exist currently. C-DAC’s work in EDA is focused on VLSI/chip design (Atman EDA) rather than PCB layout. Most Indian engineers use the same global tools described above.
Add comment